Hoard’s Dairyman Farm Creamery - SARK Triple Cream Butterkäse
Beecher's Flagship
Kingston Creamery - Amish Blue
Original Gourmet Cheese Club Selections - 2026
Please note that occasionally we are able to secure a truly special, hard to find cheese on short notice and may substitute an item.
Featured Cheeses - January 2026
- Country: United States
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-soft
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 4 weeks
SARK Triple Cream Butterkäse takes the classic German-style “butter cheese” and
amplifies its decadence with the naturally elevated butterfat of Guernsey cow’s
milk. The paste is pale gold, exceptionally smooth, and almost pudding-soft at room
temperature. On the palate, it opens with notes of sweet cream, fresh-churned
butter, and warm dairy richness before unfolding into delicate hints of cultured
crème fraîche and soft brioche.
Read More
- Country: United States
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 15 months
Beecher’s Flagship is a semi-hard cheese made from pasteurized cow’s milk. Due to
the long aging process of approximately 15 months, the cheese develops a uniquely
robust, nutty flavor. Beecher’s Flagship is extremely versatile and will work great
crumbled into an omelet or frittata, melted into macaroni and cheese, sliced for
sandwiches or burgers, or simply sliced on your cheese board. It is also a perfect
pairing with dry wines like Pouilly Fuisse or Syrah, as well as your favorite IPA or
Hefeweizen...
Read More
- Country: United States
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-soft; Blue
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 60 days
Kingston Creamery - Amish Blue Cheese is made from cow’s milk, this cheese has a
mild, earthy flavor, well balanced and flavorful. This cheese is nationally and
internationally renowned for its quality, balance and flavor. Crumble on salad or
pasta tossed with garlic and olive oil, stir into hot mashed potatoes, or make into
delicious blue cheese salad dressing. Amish Blue cheese is excellent with big, bold
red wines...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - February 2026
- Country: Italy
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 5-10 months
When the cheese is fresh, the taste is mild and delicate, and the color is white.
The texture is compact with an even oscillation, and the rind is smooth and
flexible. As the cheese matures, it becomes grainy and crumbly and the rind dries
and darkens. Its flavor becomes mellow and fruity with and full flavored finish, and
its color slowly turns to a pale, straw-yellow. Typically, you will find this cheese
served as an eating cheese with crusty bread. You can also shred it on pasta dishes,
and serve it in omelets, sauces, and fondue. Try it with Pinot Grigio...
Read More
- Country: France
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-soft
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 60 days
Port Salut is a semi-soft natural cheese that is most recognized by its orange rind.
It is rather mild with a savory, sweet flavor, unlike many other French cheeses. It
is a cheese that has universal appeal with its smooth, velvety texture and light
acidic taste. The pâte is elastic, cream-colored, soft, and supple with a very faint
aroma. Bon appetit...
Read More
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 12 months
We love Farmhouse Cheddar for its, buttery, nutty, cheddary richness, without the
slightest hint of bitterness or bite. The aroma of authentic farmhouse cheddar
should be nutty or grassy, with a rich texture and complex flavors ranging from
fruity to a woody oakiness. The color of the cheese should range from straw yellow
to beige, and the texture should be open with a few cracks… rather than rubbery and
dense, which indicates factory processing. You’ll know great cheddar if you can
still taste the sweet nuttiness several minutes after you have finished your first
mouthful...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - March 2026
- Country: The Netherlands
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 4-6 weeks
Artikaas has been making artisan cheeses in The Netherlands for six generations,
since 1890. Today’s cheesemakers combine traditional and sustainable cheesemaking
methods that date back over 2000 years with modern-day technological advances to
create enduring cheese masterpieces of texture and flavor to satisfy the growing
international demand...
Read More
- Country: Italy
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 6-9 months
This unique variety of cheese has a very distinct taste. Its aroma is strong and is
reminiscent of the fragrance of yeast and dried fruit. Occasionally one can even
distinguish a note of boiled chestnuts. To the touch, it is slightly elastic when
it's relatively young and harder when fully matured. The dark shades of yellow straw
that distinguish this variety can at times reach the intensity of amber. The sweet
taste can acquire a somewhat more savory flavor and ranges to slightly piquant. The
rich aroma becomes refined with seasoning and has a hint of dried fruit, butter and
sometimes, exotic fruits...
Read More
- Country: Spain
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Sheep
- Cheese Age: 3 months
One taste of Mahón, a smooth, supple, hard cheese named for the capital of Menorca,
will prove to any skeptic why cheese production here has become world renowned. A
unique cheese with a sweet and fruity aroma and a rich, bold flavor, Mahón is not
for those who prefer bland cheeses. Made from cow's milk, it has a yellowish rind
and a spicy and somewhat salty cheese flavor...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - April 2026
- Country: Netherlands
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 18 months
Aged 18 months, this cheese looks and feels similar to parmesan but it is more
closely related to gouda in taste and feel, offering a smooth, creamy texture
followed by a sharp, salty flavor due to its extensive aging...
Read More
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 4-6 months
White Wensleydale is firm but not dry and hard, creamy yet the surface is slightly
uneven and crumbly, and has a slightly sweet but also tart flavor. It’s sometimes
described as having a nutty, buttermilk flavor and with a honey aftertaste, and
gentle aroma of cut grass. It has a fine curd, minimal texturing, and high moisture
content. Wensleydale is usually eaten young, at about a month old. This cheese
goes...
Read More
- Country: France
- Cheese Texture / Type: Soft; Bloomy Rind
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 30 days
A bloomy rind cheese with lots of flavor, Fromage d’Affinois is mild and buttery.
Often confused with brie, its texture is similar to a creamy cheesecake. It is made
using a process known as ultra filtration. This imparts a taste like a triple-crème,
although the fat content is closer to a double-crème. Enjoy it with grapes, pears,
strawberries or crusty French bread. Accompany it with a tasty zinfandel, a
sauvignon blanc or a viognier...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - May 2026
- Country: United States
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-soft
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 2 months
Jack ‘n Dill is ivory-white with a supple, semi-soft paste generously speckled with
vibrant green dill. Its texture is smooth and slightly elastic, yielding easily to
the knife and becoming luxuriously creamy as it warms to room temperature. On the
nose, fresh dairy aromas mingle with bright herbal notes reminiscent of just-chopped
garden dill.
Read More
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 60 days
Double Gloucester is a traditional, unpasteurized, semi-hard cheese which has been
made in Gloucestershire since the sixteenth century. Records show, however, that
Gloucester was known as early as the 8th century. The hard, natural rind has some
gray-blue moulds and bears the marks of the cloth in which it is matured. Cheese
merchants used to check the rind's robustness by jumping on it with both feet to
test it! If the rind didn't crack, the cheese was safe to travel. The full-cream,
double milking sessions milk used to make Double Gloucester gives it characteristic,
rich, buttery taste and flaky texture. It is firm and bitable, like hard chocolate.
Not as firm as Cheddar, it has a mellow, nutty character with an orange-zest tang
and a hint of onion...
Read More
- Country: Italy
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Sheep
- Cheese Age: 30-60 days
The Sini Family began making Cacio de Roma more than thirty years ago on a small
dairy farm in in the countryside of Rome. Second generation master cheesemaker Uncle
Domenico Sini uses same-day sheep's milk collected from local shepherds to produce
Cacio de Roma in the same way as did his forefathers. Once the cheese obtains its
form and some texture, it is bathed in sea salt for 24 hours and then aged on wood
in cellars for thirty days. The end result is a creamy textured cheese with a mild,
balanced flavor finishing with a touch of fruit. It's the essence of the classic
Italian table cheese found universally in Central and Southern Italy. In Italy this
type of cheese is referred to as Caciotta (Kah-CHO-ta) for its small round form. Not
only is it enjoyed as a table cheese either before or after a meal, it is also used
in everyday cooking as it melts very well. Some typical uses are as a filling for
ravioli, in salads, on pizza or for simple things like grilled cheese sandwiches...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - June 2026
- Country: Italy
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Sheep
- Cheese Age: 6 months
Made with raw sheep’s milk, this cheese will have robust layers of flavors with a
gentle piquant character. Fiore Sardo is excellent by itself or on a cheese board
paired with traditional Sardinian fair such as olives, spicy salami, and rustic
bread. It is also a great grating cheese that pairs wonderfully with pestos, pastas,
and salads. For beverages, try it with a robust red or a smoky beer. Remember,
always bring your cheese up to room temperature before enjoying it.
Read More
- Country: Italy
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 3 months
Castelrosso is one of the most ancient styles of cheese from the Piemonte region of
Italy. This venerable classic is also known as Toma Brusca, which roughly translates
to “acid cheese.” The name comes from the process of letting the milk acidify
slightly before cheesemaking, which brings out tart, bright flavors and creates a
crumbly texture...
Read More
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 60 days
Five Territories from Britain's Abbey Farms is an amazing combination of five
different British cheeses that are layered on top of one another to create a one of
a kind cheese. The name is derived from the five different territories (counties) of
England of which each layered cheese is originally from: Derbyshire, Leicestershire,
Cheshire, Gloucestershire, and Somerset...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - July 2026
- Country: Switzerland
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 15 months
Swiss cheesemaking traditions date to 1815, when the country’s first cooperative
dairy was established. The Rocky 15 Month is crafted by Timon Vogel in Thurgau using
fresh regional raw milk from Switzerland’s lush pastures. Aged 15 months, it
develops a smooth, semi-firm texture with notes of toasted corn, hazelnuts, browned
butter, and dulce de leche. Pair with Bock beer, Riesling, Chardonnay, sparkling
cider, or Pinot Noir....
Read More
- Country: Spain
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Sheep
- Cheese Age: 6 months
The cheese has a hard, dry texture yet is feels pleasantly oily when consumed. It is
a real favorite of those who enjoy a tasty, chewy cheese. Adherents rave about its
distinctive rich, buttery flavor and perfumed aroma. Even its hard, orange-brown
rind is edible. The cheese is often served with a full-bodied Spanish red wine and
is considered a perfect companion for grilled or barbequed meats, which makes it
especially appealing for summertime barbeques as an added treat. One culinary
recommendation: it is perfect to melt on top of barbequed burgers. How ironic that
the most famous of Basque cheeses should find notoriety on America’s outdoor grills!
Read More
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 3 months
Real farmhouse Cheshire, like the one we so proudly bring to you this month, comes
from the county of Cheshire. This northern part of England is irrigated by the River
Dee. The county was originally made famous for sheep's milk cheeses, but Cheshire
was always made from cow's milk as are most cheeses in northern England today. To be
called Cheshire, the cheese must be made from milk derived from the Cheshire area
pastures and made in that same locale, using specific cheesemaking processes and a
minimum age...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - August 2026
- Country: Spain
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 6 months
- Milk Treatment: Pasteurized
A traditional Spanish cow's milk cheese from the island of Menorca, Mahón Semi
Curado is aged for six months to develop a firm texture with rich buttery notes,
toasted nuts, and a pleasantly tangy finish. An excellent table cheese that also
melts beautifully for cooking.
Read More
- Country: USA
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 2 months
- Milk Treatment: Pasteurized
Crafted by Wisconsin's renowned Carr Valley Cheese Company, this semi-firm Fontina
offers a smooth, creamy texture with rich buttery notes, delicate nuttiness, and
exceptional melting qualities. A versatile American take on the classic Italian
cheese, it's equally at home on a cheeseboard or in your favorite comfort foods.
Read More
- Country: Spain
- Cheese Texture / Type: Soft
- Milk Type: Goat
- Cheese Age: 2 weeks
- Milk Treatment: Pasteurized
A fresh Spanish goat cheese with a luxuriously soft, creamy texture and bright,
tangy character. Aged just two weeks, Capricho de Cabra delivers delicate citrus
notes, subtle herbal nuances, and a clean finish, making it a refreshing addition to
cheeseboards, salads, or warm crusty bread.
Read More
Featured Cheeses - September 2026
- Country: Spain
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow, Goat, Sheep
- Cheese Age: 3-6 months
Spanish Ibérico is rich and savory, with a firm yet creamy texture and flavors of
sweet milk, toasted nuts, butter, and gentle earthiness. Sheep’s milk contributes
richness, while goat’s milk brings a light tang that balances the softer cow’s-milk
character. Serve it with Marcona almonds, quince paste, olives, cured Spanish meats,
roasted peppers, or crusty bread. It also works beautifully grated or melted into
warm dishes.
Read More
- Country: Netherlands
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 4-6 weeks
Youngsters Chimichurri Gouda is pale ivory in color with a firm, yet velvety paste
that becomes even more luscious and creamy as it becomes warm. It will captivate
your taste buds with young Gouda flavors like sweet cream and toasted nuts, dashed
with the Argentinian-style chimichurri spices of cilantro, fresh parsley, and garlic
found throughout the paste. Rich and buttery...
Read More
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 3-4 months
Cotswold is essentially a double gloucester cheese, with the addition of chives.
this has a creamy flavour, and the chives add a nice tang of herbs to the taste.
Like double gloucester it is orange in colour, and semi firm in texture...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - October 2026
- Country: United States
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 1-3 months
Red Dragon delivers buttery cheddar, savory malt, gentle tang, and a distinctive
mustard bite, with whole mustard seeds adding an appealing textural contrast. Serve
with pretzels, crusty bread, apples, pickles, cured meats, roasted potatoes, or
burgers. It makes an excellent grilled cheese and melts beautifully over potatoes or
toast. For beverages, try brown ale, English pale ale, amber ale, hard cider,
Cabernet Sauvignon, or a medium-bodied red wine.
Read More
- Country: Netherlands
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 12 months
If you love Gouda and Parmesan, this month’s Two Sisters Isabella Aged Gouda is
going to knock your socks off and quickly become your new favorite. Technically
speaking, this cheese isn’t a traditional Gouda. Rather, it’s an offshoot known as
Proosdij—a semi-firm to firm cheese that blends mesophilic and thermophilic starter
cultures, resulting in characteristics reminiscent of both Gouda and Parmesan.
Read More
- Country: Germany
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 1 month
Aged for one month, German Butterkäse is a traditional German cow’s milk cheese
known for its smooth, supple texture and delicate buttery flavor. Mild and creamy
with a gentle tang, it has an inviting melt that makes it wonderfully versatile for
both snacking and cooking...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - November 2026
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: A few weeks
Clawson Crimson® is mild, creamy, lightly tangy, and crumbly, with the cranberries
contributing bright notes of sweet and tart fruit. Serve it with apples, pears,
toasted walnuts, shortbread, oatcakes, honey, or fruit preserves. It also works
beautifully crumbled into salads or incorporated into baked goods. For beverages,
try off-dry Riesling, sparkling wine, hard cider, fruit-forward wheat beer, or a
Belgian-style golden ale.
Read More
- Country: England
- Cheese Texture / Type: Semi-firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 10 months
The helveticus culture creates a slightly fractured or crunchy texture – which
results in this cheese’s hallmark crumble and snap when you bite it – making it the
perfect cheddar for your cheeseboard. To serve, allow it to warm to room temperature
to release all the flavors. While it is visually beautiful, it also has an
irresistible flavor profile – it’s delicate, slightly sweet, and savory – with notes
of toasted nuts and caramel.
Read More
- Country: United States
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 9 months
Based in Southeast Iowa, Milton Creamery was started in 2006 as a joint venture by
the Musser Family and local Amish dairy farmers. Today the creamery is solely owned
and operated by the Musser Family with the addition of a couple of outside
employees. Soon after opening, 17 year old Galen Musser submitted his take on
cheddar, Prairie Breeze, and won Best of Class in the Open Hard category at the U.S.
Cheese Championship which is one of many awards. Sweeter than most cheddars, this
well aged cheddar is loaded with flavor with the added crunch of calcium crystals
developed during the aging process...
Read More
Featured Cheeses - December 2026
- Country: France
- Cheese Texture / Type: Soft-ripened / triple cream
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: Ripened soft cheese; exact days vary
Belletoile® is lush, buttery, creamy, and mellow, with delicate mushroom, nut,
sweet cream, and gentle tangy notes. Serve it near room temperature with baguette,
pears, apples, grapes, figs, honey, toasted almonds, or fruit preserves. For
beverages, its richness is especially good with Champagne, Crémant, Chardonnay, dry
Riesling, Saison, Belgian-style golden ale, or a crisp hard cider.
Read More
- Country: Switzerland
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 3-6 months
Swiss Raclette offers creamy, nutty, savory, and gently earthy flavors, becoming
richer and more aromatic when melted. Traditionally, scrape the warm cheese over
boiled or roasted potatoes and accompany it with cornichons, pickled onions,
charcuterie, mushrooms, or roasted vegetables. Pair it with dry Swiss white wine,
Riesling, Chasselas, hard cider, Saison, or a crisp lager, choosing refreshing
beverages that balance the melted cheese’s richness.
Read More
- Country: United States
- Cheese Texture / Type: Firm
- Milk Type: Cow
- Cheese Age: 6 months
Grafton Village Truffle Cheddar combines savory cheddar tang with earthy mushroom,
truffle, butter, and concentrated umami flavors. Serve with crusty bread, roasted
mushrooms, potatoes, charcuterie, toasted walnuts, or simple crackers. It is
especially luxurious melted into grilled cheese, macaroni and cheese, risotto, eggs,
or burgers. Pair with Champagne, Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, brown ale, porter, or a
Belgian-style ale.
Read More
Experience International Variety
You might receive a Gaperon, originating in France during the 14th Century, an
authentic Lancashire by Ruth Kirkham, and an Italian Taleggio matured in the
caves of Valsassina…all in one shipment!
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
Our 100% Satisfaction Guarantee ensures that every product you purchase from any of our clubs meets your high standards, contact us within 30 days and we will do our best to make it right or you may cancel your membership at anytime and receive a full refund for any unshipped product.